Baer Insurance Services

Contact Us

Baer Insurance Services
9701 Brader Way, Suite 101
Middleton, WI 53562

Tel: (608) 830-5800
Toll Free: (888) 729-2237
Fax: (608) 830-5877
Email: Send Email

Office Hours: M-F 8:00am to 4:30pm

Mailing Address:
Baer Insurance Services
P.O. Box 46490
Madison, WI 53744

  • Communicate With Us


    We would love to hear from you! Please complete this simple form and we will get in touch with you soon.

Our Team of Insurance

Professionals

Our focus is to help you make an informed decision about the coverage and policy options you have to be confident in your level of protection and pleased with the process.

Administration

Keith Kaetterhenry

CEO

Patrick Kelly

President

Jonathon Zwettler

Vice President of Sales

Kristin Oster

Human Resources / Office Manager

Commercial Lines

Stan Heller

Senior Account Executive

Ryan Burns

Senior Account Executive

Hillary Pink-Budworth

Senior Account Executive

Brendan Woods

Account Executive

Joey Broms

Account Executive

Mike Zagrodnik

Account Executive
Municipalities

Sheila Blum

Account Manager
Epic Systems Specialist

Nikki Huseth

Account Manager

Megan Corace

Account Manager

Jess Sorenson

Account Manager

Samantha Carroll

Samantha Carroll

Account Manager

Christina Karls

Christina Karls

Account Manager

Mary Jo Nowak

Mary Jo Nowak

Account Manager

Cary Neess

Small Business Specialist

Padee Thor

Padee Thor

Small Business Specialist

Michael Ingalls

Michael Ingalls

Small Business Specialist

Brian Kaetterhenry

Marketing Center Specialist

Barbara Conway

Marketing Center Specialist

Personal Lines

Melanie Penshorn

Senior Account Executive

Jennie Owens

Account Executive

Mike Peterson

Account Executive

Julie Smith

Account Executive

Erich Froemming

Erich Froemming

Account Executive

Leah Sinner

Leah Sinner

Account Executive

Employee Benefits

Lars Shultz

Lars Schultz

Benefits Account Executive

Pam Higinbotham

Pam Higinbotham

Account Manager

Life Insurance

Whitneyt Biddick

Whitney Biddick

Account Executive

Support

Kimberly Shea

Digital/Media Specialist

Beverly Petrolis

Receptionist

Helen Kitelinger

P & C Admin Assistant

Geoffrey Montgomery

Admin Assistant

Maggie Edge

Maggie Rothmann

Project Specialist

Kelly Deneen

Kelly Deneen

Associate Account Manager

Middleton, WI

Location